How to explain why you no longer celebrate Halloween, Christmas, Easter, or other traditions without building a wall
A woman recently contacted us asking for help. Her dilemma is something we hear every day.
She had declined an invitation to a Halloween party. Her husband was annoyed and told her it was “just for fun.” She knew some of the same people would probably invite them to a Christmas party they had attended in previous years, and she did not know what she would say then, either. And she said she didn’t even want to think about Easter.
She felt self-conscious and awkward. She was afraid she would stumble over her words. When the people questioned her, she began second-guessing herself.
She didn’t know how to handle the situation, what to say, or the best way to respond when confronted with it.
She was not asking, “Can someone give me the strongest argument against Halloween?” She was asking:
“How do I explain a new conviction when I’m nervous, my husband is annoyed, and the people around me may not understand?”
That is a very different question.
She is already vulnerable. She is changing. Her marriage is feeling the strain. She is trying to obey what she believes Yehovah is showing her while learning how to explain something she may not fully know how to put into words yet.
And much of the advice amounted to: Announce the verdict. Tell them you do Bible things. Explain that they celebrate darkness. Walk away.
We see this question all the time. Sometimes in our inbox, sometimes posted publicly. And the answers are a mixed bag ranging from “just do it to keep the peace” to “tell them you don’t celebrate the pagan traditions anymore because you don’t want to go to hell!”
Holy cow, Batman!
Sometimes the responses are thoughtful. A commenter may recognize that the conversation might look different with a believer than with an unbeliever. Another suggested leaving the door open for a longer conversation over coffee.
Those are pieces of a bridge.
But much of the advice? Yikes on bikes.
It may communicate a boundary, but it does not necessarily preserve the relationship. It certainly does not help a frightened woman carry her conviction with confidence, humility, and grace.
So as I listened to this woman sharing her conundrum and the “advice” she was getting, one thing jumped out at me:
Where are the bridges?
So, put on your hard hat. We’re gonna talk about building bridges.
Answer the Question They Actually Asked
A party invitation is not necessarily a request for a complete theological defense of your convictions.
Sometimes all you need to say is:
“Thank you for inviting me. I’m not participating this year, but I really appreciate you thinking of me.”
That is a complete answer.
You are allowed to decline an invitation without presenting a Bible study, defending every conclusion you have reached, or persuading the other person to agree with you.
If they ask why, you can say:
“I’ve been studying and reconsidering some things I have always celebrated. I’m trying to follow what I believe God is showing me, even though I’m still learning how to explain it.”
Side note here. Talk to them in terms they understand. If they use “God” and “Jesus,” using Yehovah or any other name will just add to confusion and conflict. You are not denying Yehovah by speaking to a person who “doesn’t understand – yet” using the terms and names that are familiar to them.
That’s another stone in your bridge.
The response itself is honest. It does not weaken your conviction, and it does not accuse the other person. It leaves the door open if they are sincerely interested.
If they want to know more, you might say:
“I began asking whether the celebrations I participate in actually come from Scripture and whether they honor God in the way He asks to be honored. I’m still working through it carefully, but I’m no longer comfortable participating.”
You do not have to pretend you have every answer before you obey what you can already see.
Your Boundary Does Not Need an Accusation Attached to It
There is an important difference between stating your conviction and assigning motives to someone else.
“I’m not comfortable participating in Halloween” describes your decision.
“You celebrate death, fear, and darkness” tells the other person what you believe about them.
Even when you have serious biblical concerns about a holiday, beginning with an accusation will usually make someone defend themselves before they ever hear the concern. They probably do not believe they are celebrating death. They believe they are wearing costumes, laughing with friends, and handing out candy.
That does not say that the participation is right. It simply tells us where the other person is standing.
And that’s important. If you are going to reach them, you are going to have to find them where they are – just like Yeshua.
If we want to help someone see what we have seen in Scripture, we need to meet them there.
Where are the bridges?
“I Do Bible Things” May Not Communicate What You Think It Does
I’ve seen people suggest “biblical” responses like, “If it’s in the Bible, I do it. If it isn’t, I don’t,” or, “We do Bible things in Bible ways.”
I understand what they mean. I also understand how those words may sound to a Christian who believes they too are doing Bible things in Bible ways.
So, what do you think they hear?
“I obey the Bible. You do not.”
“I am holy. You are not.”
“I have a relationship with Jesus. You do not.”
That does not invite them to examine Scripture. It puts them on trial.
“If it isn’t in the Bible, I don’t do it” is not really an accurate explanation, either. We do plenty of ordinary things that are not specifically mentioned in Scripture. The real question is not whether every activity appears by name in the Bible. The question is whether it agrees with biblical truth, honors Yehovah, and belongs in the life of someone who abides in Yeshua.
We need to know what we believe. We need Scripture beneath our conviction. But the Bible is the foundation beneath your conviction – it is not the club you use to punish someone who does not share it yet.
Open the Bible. Don’t beat them over the head with it.
What About Her Husband?
This may be the most important part of her question—and the easiest part to overlook.
Her greatest difficulty may not be declining the party. It may be living through a changing conviction inside a marriage where her husband has not reached the same conclusion.
He may feel blindsided. They attended these events before. Now she is saying no. Christmas is coming, and he may already be wondering how much more is about to change.
That does not mean she should violate her conviction to keep him comfortable. It does mean she should recognize that he is experiencing this change too.
She might say:
“I know this feels sudden because we have gone to these things before. I’m not trying to embarrass you, control you, or suggest that I am better than you. I’ve become uncomfortable participating, and I need to be honest about that. I would like to explain what I’m seeing when we can talk without pressure.”
That is very different from announcing, “I studied the Bible, and we are not doing pagan holidays anymore.”
One opens a conversation. The other hands down a ruling.
Where are the bridges?
And she does not have to solve Christmas in the same conversation. Halloween is in front of them now. Christmas can be discussed when they have time to listen to one another.
Conviction does not have to arrive in the marriage swinging a wrecking ball.
The best thing she can do is find the areas where they have unity and build from there.
She can also ask what part of the change concerns him most. Listening does not require her to surrender her conviction. It helps her understand where the bridge needs to begin.
They Are Asking About Your Hope
Peter wrote:
“But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts: and be ready always to give an answer to every man that asketh you a reason of the hope that is in you with meekness and fear.”
— 1 Peter 3:15
We often focus on be ready to give an answer.
But look at what they are asking about.
Your hope.
Not merely your rules. Not merely the holidays you no longer celebrate. Not a list of everything you believe other Christians are doing wrong.
Something in you has caused them to notice hope—and now they want to know where it came from.
That hope should carry joy and peace. You have discovered something beautiful in Scripture. You have begun to see Yehovah’s appointed times, His ways, His plan, and His invitation to walk with Him.
You are not simply leaving traditions behind. You are moving toward something.
That should be exciting.
When someone asks why you no longer celebrate Halloween, Christmas, Easter, or another tradition, they may be doing more than questioning your decision. They may be looking for a bridge.
They may have noticed that you are different. They may be uncomfortable with traditions they have never known how to question. They may be searching for people who understand what they are beginning to see.
Or maybe they haven’t seen anything yet but long for a deeper relationship with Yehovah. They watch you and see the peace and joy, the hope you have in you, and they wonder, “What do they have that I don’t?”
People naturally look for community. When their convictions begin to change, they start looking for others who can help them understand where they are going—and reassure them that they will not have to walk there alone.
What will they find when they come to you? Will they find joy, peace, and someone eager to open Scripture and walk beside them? Or will they find contempt for the people they still love, criticism of everything they once did, and a wall of information they are expected to climb before they are welcomed?
Where are the bridges?
Sharing your hope does not mean weakening the truth. It means remembering what the truth gave you – and helping others find those same answers.
You found something worth walking toward. Now someone is asking you why.
The door is open.
Do not hit them with it.
Invite them to walk with you.
We Did Not Disconnect From Yehovah
People may look at what we no longer celebrate and assume that we have lost something.
Sometimes they assume we have become less joyful, less connected, or even less Christian. People who don’t understand—yet—often picture believers who celebrate the feast days as solemn, serious, and even “burdened” with the “work” of keeping these days Yehovah gave us.
I know that’s not true. YOU know it’s not true.
But they might not know.
And because they don’t know, they may assume we have disconnected from Yehovah—or “moved away from God.”
But that is not our testimony.
We did not disconnect from Yehovah when we left those traditions. We connected with Him on a deeper level.
We began asking what He calls holy and actually listened to HIS answers. We discovered the days He appointed for His people. We wanted to BE His people, so we moved closer to Him to become His people.
We found His rhythm of work, rest, remembrance, rejoicing, repentance, and anticipation – we tasted and saw that Yehovah is good.
We stopped trying to fit Him into celebrations He never gave us and began learning how He invited His people to meet with Him. We stopped worshipping Him our way and started doing it His way.
That did not leave an empty space in our lives. It filled one.
We did not stop celebrating because we wanted less of Yehovah. We changed because we wanted more of Him.
That is part of the hope within us.
When someone asks why you no longer celebrate Halloween, Christmas, Easter, or another traditional holiday, do not tell them only what you left.
Tell them what you found.
Let them hear the joy in your voice when you speak about Sabbath. Tell them what Passover taught you about redemption. Tell them how the Feast of Unleavened Bread caused you to examine what needed to be removed from your life. Tell them why Pentecost matters.
Tell them how Yom Teruah fills you with anticipation, how Yom Kippur calls you to examine your heart, and how Sukkot teaches you to rejoice before Yehovah and look toward His coming Kingdom.
And let them hear—feel—your joy and excitement!
This is not a life emptied of celebration. It is a life learning to celebrate with purpose.
If all they hear is what you are against, they may never discover what you are walking toward.
Where are the bridges?
When You Are Invited to Participate
This is often where the conversation begins.
A relative invites you to Christmas dinner. A friend invites you to a Halloween party. Your workplace announces a gift exchange. Your child is asked to participate in a holiday activity at school. A church invites your family to an Easter program.
The person inviting you may not be challenging your faith. They may simply be including you because they care about you.
Receive the kindness in the invitation even if you cannot accept the activity. You do not have to respond to a friendly invitation as though someone has called you to a public debate.
And you can put your Bible down for now.
You don’t build bridges by charging at people with a Bible in one hand and a sword in the other, screaming a war cry that reverberates in their bones.
That’s a terrifying image, and it decimates all the bridges.
If You Simply Need to Decline
“Thank you for thinking of us. We won’t be participating, but I really appreciate the invitation.”
That may be all the moment requires.
If This Is the First Time You Have Declined
The person may be confused because you participated in previous years. You can say:
“I know this is different because we have joined you before. I’ve been studying and reconsidering some of the traditions I have always celebrated, and I’m no longer comfortable participating. I’m still grateful that you included us.”
You have acknowledged the change without pretending the other person should already understand it.
Plus, this makes it a you thing. You are not putting them on the defensive or going for their throat. You’re simply saying, “I’ve reevaluated some things, and I’m no longer participating.”
That’s a stone in the bridge you are building.
If Someone Asks Why
“As I began studying Scripture more closely, I started asking whether the celebrations I participate in were given by God and whether they honor Him in the way He asks to be honored. That has changed some of my decisions.”
That answer explains your conviction without assigning a motive to them.
If They Are Sincerely Interested
“We did not stop celebrating because we wanted less of God. We began learning about the days He appointed in Scripture, and they have helped us connect with Him on a deeper level. I would love to show you what I’ve been studying if you want to talk about it.”
There is the hope. There is the open door. There is the bridge.
If They Dismiss Your Conviction
Someone may tell you:
- “It’s just for fun.”
- “You are taking this too seriously.”
- “God knows my heart.”
- “We don’t think of it that way.”
- “You can make it about Jesus.”
- “You used to celebrate it.”
- “That is against God.”
- “All that stuff is for the Jews.”
You do not have to answer every statement.
Try:
“I understand that you see it differently. I’m not asking you to reach my conclusion today, but I do need you to respect that I’m trying to be faithful to what I believe Yehovah has shown me.”
If they continue:
“I care about our relationship, and I don’t want this to become an argument. My answer is still no, but the door is open if you ever want to understand why.”
That is a boundary with a bridge attached.
If You Want to Preserve the Relationship
Very often, people who are told, “We don’t celebrate that,” see it as a personal rejection. Keep that in mind.
Declining a holiday activity does not have to mean declining the person. When appropriate, offer another opportunity to spend time together:
“We won’t be attending the Christmas party, but we would love to have dinner with you another evening.”
Or:
“We aren’t participating in Halloween, but we would still love to get the children together another weekend.”
Do not offer an alternative because you feel guilty or because someone refuses to accept your boundary. Offer it because you want the person to know:
“I am saying no to this activity. I am not saying no to you.”
That distinction can keep a relationship from becoming another unnecessary casualty of changing convictions.
Build Your Bridge Before the Conversation Happens
You may not know when someone will ask why you no longer participate in a holiday or tradition, but you can prepare before they do.
Not so you can deliver a rehearsed speech or win an argument. Prepare so that nervousness does not make you say more than you intended—or say it more sharply than you intended.
Prepare so that when someone begins looking for a bridge, you are ready to show them one.
1. Remember What You Found
Before you write down everything you left, write down what you found.
Ask yourself:
- What did I discover about Yehovah?
- What became clearer when I began studying Scripture?
- What joy have His appointed times brought into my home?
- What peace came from no longer forcing tradition to fit the Bible?
- What am I moving toward?
- What hope do I now have that I want someone else to see?
If your entire explanation is about paganism, corruption, deception, and everything wrong with other people’s celebrations, you have explained what you oppose.
You have not yet explained your hope.
Your loved ones need to know that you have not simply become the person who refuses everything.
You have found something.
Let them see it.
2. Write Down What You Actually Believe
Can you explain your conviction in one or two sentences without talking about what everyone else is doing wrong?
Begin here:
“I no longer participate in this celebration because…”
Then finish the sentence honestly.
Do not copy someone else’s strongest statement. Do not borrow a conclusion you have never studied. Write what you currently understand and where you see it in Scripture.
If you cannot explain the conviction without becoming angry, attacking someone else, or pointing out someone else’s error, you may need more time with the Word before you try to explain it to another person.
3. Find the Scripture Beneath Your Conviction
You do not need a stack of twenty verses to throw onto the table. Begin with two or three portions of Scripture you have studied in context.
Ask:
- Who is speaking?
- Who is being addressed?
- What practice or problem is being discussed?
- What principle does the Scripture establish?
- How does that principle apply to the celebration or tradition I am reconsidering?
The goal is not to collect ammunition. The goal is to make sure Scripture—not social media, a persuasive teacher, fear, or pressure—is carrying the weight of your conviction.
4. Prepare Three Answers
Not every question requires the same response. Prepare an answer for three different situations.
The simple answer:
“Thank you for inviting me. I’m not participating this year, but I appreciate you thinking of me.”
The personal answer:
“I’ve been studying some of the traditions I have always participated in, and I’m no longer comfortable celebrating this one.”
The deeper answer:
“I began asking whether the celebrations I participate in come from Scripture and whether they honor God in the way He asks to be honored. I would be glad to show you what I’ve been studying if you are interested.”
You do not have to give the deeper answer to someone who only needs the simple one.
And each of these has the potential to open up a Bible study instead of starting an argument.
5. Practice Saying It Out Loud
This may feel silly.
Do it anyway.
Say your answer while you are folding laundry, driving, washing dishes, or standing in front of a mirror. Ask someone you trust to practice the conversation with you.
When you have already heard the words come out of your mouth, you are less likely to freeze, ramble, or become defensive when the real question comes.
Preparation is not pretending. It is putting a tool in your hand before you need it.
6. Decide What Your Boundary Is
Be specific.
Are you declining the party? Are you choosing not to decorate? Are you keeping your children home from an event? Are you declining a gift exchange, holiday meal, or church program?
Know what your boundary is before pressure arrives. Then state what you will do without trying to control everyone else.
“I won’t be participating.”
That is a boundary.
“None of you should be doing this.”
That begins a different conversation—and it may not be the conversation you were invited to have.
7. Prepare Your Heart Too
Before you speak, ask yourself:
- Am I trying to help this person see, or am I trying to prove that I am right?
- Am I prepared to listen?
- Can I answer without insulting their intelligence or questioning their love for Yehovah?
- Am I willing to say, “I don’t know yet, but I will study it”?
- Will my attitude make them more willing—or less willing—to open Scripture with me later?
You can have a correct position and still carry it with the wrong spirit.
Good fruit does not weaken truth. It makes the truth easier to see.
8. Leave the Door Open
You do not have to finish the entire conversation today.
You can say:
“I know this may seem strange because I used to celebrate it too. If you ever want to know what changed my mind, I would be glad to sit down with you and look at the Scriptures together.”
Then stop.
Let them decide whether to walk through the open door.
You do not have to chase them through it.
Pray About Everything
Pray before you have the conversation. Pray after the conversation. Pray for the people you talk to, regardless of how they received what you told them.
Ask Yehovah to change you.
Yes, that’s right. If you are going to minister to people. If you are going to reach people. If you are going to answer their questions with grace and most of all love, then you are going to have to change.
Maybe you need to change an attitude, a behavior, a belief – or maybe you need to have that love for people that Yeshua does.
If you want the people you love to change, it all starts with Yehovah changing you.
Ask Him to make you the person that they need to come to His truth, to understand His Word, and to become the people that He wants them to be.
Prayer is the foundation of everything.
And if you don’t have a prayer life, all of this is going to be much harder.
Do Not Force Open a Door
Not every invitation will become a Bible study. Not every question is sincere. Not every person is ready to hear everything you have learned.
Share when someone asks. Explain when they want to understand. Open Scripture when they are willing to look.
When they open the door, be ready. When they begin looking for a bridge, show them one.
But do not chase someone down the road, build a bridge in front of them, and demand that they cross it immediately while waving your Bible over your head like a weapon.
The Word of Yehovah is a weapon against the enemy, not against unsuspecting people who are still figuring things out—like we all are—but are just not quite as far down the road.
Their best chance is to see how this truth affects your life. Let them see the transformation you are experiencing as you draw closer to your Creator. Let them see the joy on your face and the peace in your home.
Have you ever passed a burger joint and smelled the burgers cooking? It made you hungry, didn’t it? You started thinking, “Man, that smells so good! I want some of that!”
It works in the Spirit too.
Let them smell what you’re cooking.
If they are hungry, they’ll pull up a chair at your table and say, “Now, tell me about this Yeshua.”
The Holy Spirit has a job here.
Let Him do it.
The Goal Is Not a Perfect Defense
Your goal is faithfulness.
Know what you believe. Know where you see it in Scripture. Speak clearly, show good fruit, and respect the person standing in front of you.
You are not responsible for forcing them to agree. You are responsible for making sure your words and your spirit do not hide the hope you want them to see.
Defend your faith. Protect your boundary. Keep the door open.
And before you speak, ask:
Where are the bridges?
Then find them – or build them.
Subscribe to the Torah Observant Apostolic Newsletter! It’s free!
